So the downside is all of 0.22 damage per turn, which I think is probably less than OP envisioned. It is such a fun deck to play, and my go to deck in modern. Originally i was planning on trying to get a playset of Dark Confidant Start one on this topic we can hash it out there :). Damage can be prevented, for example, but loss of life cant. Trespassers Curse doesnt look like much, but you get to drain those pesky token players. This site is unaffiliated. Of course that depends on what you're comparing, but it's a fair statement. i agree with you sir, dark confidant is useless and i will never play one, if you find you are losing too much life then just make sure the creatures you do have, have lifelink or just use hella killspells to keep their board clear while you beat them with the Griselbrand Charles Baker "Dill" Harris, the nephew of Miss Rachel, becomes quick friends with Jem and Scout during his first summer in Maycomb. For the same mana Night's Whisper immediately gives you two cards at the cost of two life. Nonetheless, I do think it's the best information we have available. Show All Versions. Unless you're doing like no ban modern. After the third card the odds that the game has not ended drop significantly, as it becomes increasingly likely that someone has won the game by that point. All of the points raised above are extremely valid, but it all comes down to the mana. The money i would have spent on a new standard deck i got kiki pod at the time. Dark Depths is banned in modern. The Scarab God makes your opponents lose X life, where X is the number of zombies you control. Dark Confidant The . I must admit, I'm picking up a playset of Bobs atm, all new art for my cube and my next deck project which is gonna be jund or bug. I play B/G/R(Jund colors) in modern, my deck was around $300 to build. Lightning Bolt, for example, does not count as a life loss card because it deals damage rather than causing a player to lose life. You get card advantage, drain life, and your opponent loses something when the card enters the battlefield. So for 8 fetchlands and those 8 staples, you're already over 1k. Please enable JavaScript on your browser to best view this site. Absolutely no guarantee is made for any price information. In fact, compared to all the other ubiquitous card advantage engines Bob falls short. I was surprised to see a card like [[Dark Confidant]] come back at such a hefty price for the ability that it has. Judge Gift Cards. These cookies help us improve our product by analyzing user data and applying personalized functions. The ability to dig through your deck is probably why most games end by turn 5. Dark Confidant has since been reprinted three times, in both Modern Masters and Modern Masters 2015 Edition, as well as a DCI Promotional card. Fguiont Racing Club. If you look like an adept card handler and always win, . Assuming we get him out on Turn 2, and assuming no removal, Bob will draw two cards over two turns with reasonable consistency. His biggest MTG regret is trading a bunch of Force of Wills for Serra Angels. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. I don't think that KingSorin is trying to compare Bob and Lili per se, but to say that you expect to get more out of a 3-drop. And it's not really excuses, I'm just putting numbers down. At the beginning of your upkeep, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. I'm also not convinced that they are worth running - Grob has the same speed as Bob, and can be blocked by something as trivial as a Forbidden Orchard activation. Ravnica: Dark Confidant Add To Wishlist Restock Notice Gatherer & Rulings NM EX VG G 4 available $17.84 Add to Cart Sell your Dark Confidant Switch to Foil Other Versions Show All Versions Customers who purchased Ravnica: Dark Confidant also bought. Senseis Divining Top lets you pay 1 mana to look at the top 3 cards of your library and put them in any order. If you can't afford the card, don't just replace it and expect the deck to work, cause it won't. But, yeah, I wonder the same goddam thing every time I see it cast. Types: Creature Human Wizard. Privacy Policy. Contrasting Dark Confidant with Night's Whisper then, as an easy comparison, I am not absolutely certain that he is better. You cast Mind Rot and knock two cards out of your opponent's hand. DevoidMage I realize that Don't ask me what my reasoning was for putting it here, because even I don't know. now i know that this post is about bob but i was addressing a modern issue in general. Illustrated by Scott M. Fischer 2/1 not legal standard not legal historic 10 COMMENTS | Is there a single-word adjective for "having exceptionally strong moral principles"? It is not so. 5 out of 5 stars (1,997) Sale Price $4.70 $ 4.70 $ 5.54 Original Price $5.54 . The difference with Modern of course is that with "rotation", all I have to do is add a Scavenging Ooze Bile Blight: Disease Targeting a Specific Creature Type. He works with Tymna, he dies to Skullclamp, as a 2/1 he can block a lot of relevant creatures, etc. My point is when you go up 1 mana, the expectations the card has to fill drastically increase. The lack of a real legacy scene their does make certain cards cheaper. It would be abetter option that Dark Confidant. The Meathook Massacre combines a sweeper and a lifedrain effect in one tool. I was going under the assumption that someone would only focus on building a single T1 deck for a particular standard, so you saying you'd have to sell all of your decks to fund modern just helps my argument. Debt to the Deathless | Illustration by Seb McKinnon. Description Details Dark Confidant Size - 8.8cm x 6.3cm, Fit perfectly into KMC perfect fit sleeve. Dark Confidant AP. If I were to use Blood Scrivener Replacement For Dark Confidant. There were lots of cards to choose from and narrowing down to a list wasnt easy, but I tried to get the most powerful, popular, and competitive ones out there. @wesdfgfgd Why not? The strategic implications of Magic are intricate and complicated. A turn by turn analysis follows, so that it can be compared with the theoretical basic curve. For the effects of cards like Astarion, the Decadent and Archfiend of Despair, all loss of life is measured by the variation of the life in that turn (also known as life swing). You will find further information on individual cookies in our Privacy Policy, where you can adjust your cookie settings. Zodiac Dragon MTG from Portal Three Kingdoms. Card prices and promotional offers represent daily estimates and/or market values provided by our affiliates. I have no idea how much I "spent" on it because the cards were gathered piecemeal, all the way down to opening Voice of Resurgence We find that whole communities suddenly fix their minds upon one object, and go mad in its pursuit; that millions of people become simultaneously impressed with one delusion, and run after it . 4) Dark Confidant costs 1 black, Arena costs 2 black, makeing Confidant easier to splash and easier to ensure you get into play right away. But youll get an extra card and lose some life every turn if your Confidant lives, which is excellent against control and midrange strategies. Dark Confidant Double Masters Box Toppers | Magic | CardTrader Magic: the Gathering Double Masters Box Toppers Singles Dark Confidant Double Masters Box Toppers #342 Double Masters Box Toppers (342) View all 7 versions Info Sell CT Min Price CT Market Price US Market Price $27.07 The card's flavor text alludes to Maher's epithet "the Great One". Press J to jump to the feed. Yes. So if two players exchange life when one is at 10 and the other is at 30, the player who had 30 life will have 10 at the end of the process, thus having lost 20 life. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Any deck he is slapped in makes that deck 10 times better. On top of having the Dark Confidant effect, Sorin the Mirthless can generate vampires with lifelink and can take over a game with card advantage while also of being good against aggro. I had most of it, but I recently had to purchase the fetchlands and no one on TCG Player was cutting any breaks. The stars gutter and the skies fade and the earth grows weary with years. People are free to interpret it how they wish. @ Matsi883 confused why you would link that? does not, but the only one you even need is that it costs one less mana. you just drew for one life. . For example, Jund can run every modern-legal fetchland. Set: Ravnica: City of Guilds. @SocioMatt Blood Scrivener is the Dark Confidant. You lose life equal to its mana value. Do Obosh and Brash Taunter together cause quadruple damage to an opponent? Contact | This site 2023 TappedOut.net, LLC Dark Confidant {1} {B} Creature Human Wizard At the beginning of your upkeep, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. Ages of men and of Outsiders have ascended and been forgotten, and only the bones of their cities and the Is Loss of Life Considered Noncombat Damage? Mana Cost: Converted Mana Cost: 2. I worry that semantic wrangling is diluting the answer that OP was looking for. As I mentioned, it can be sacrificed easier than any of the other cards and more reliably based on the general cEDH meta. Fifth turn: Another land, two-drop, and finally a three-drop lead us to 22 two-drops/land, and four three-drops, totaling the deck out at 60 cards. Why are non-Western countries siding with China in the UN. Heres Vito, Thorn of the Dusk Rose, one that can block, attack, and costs only three mana all while having two relevant creature types. If your intention is card advantage (which it is, when you're playing with Dark Confidant) in no way is Liliana of the Veil better. CardTrader All versions from all sets for Dark Confidant | CardTrader Games Magic: the Gathering Pokmon Yu-Gi-Oh! Coming into a blind meta, I would like to include a Bob in the deck to keep the mana curve low for Ad Nauseam, have a creature to pitch to Razaketh, an extra Tymna draw, or a blocker for whatever, etc. KingSorin raises another very important point in sort of a sideways manner. Magic:. Dark Confidant is a game changer in deck building. Rotorua Racing Club. Its kinda like a Howling Mine except that your opponents dont draw any extra cards! A 6/5 flying demon is good. Mana Cost: Card Type: Creature - Human Wizard. While his ceiling may be higher (a T1 Bob would draw 4 in the same situation), his floor is abysmal. Blocks Tymna, too. Whether it's the price you pay or not, it's at least useful for comparative discussions (rather than devolving into "$1200! And I can always count on long-time friend and confidant, Bruce Samboy, to look over my shoulder with a lceen, investigator's eye; . Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. How do I align things in the following tabular environment? I'm not the smartest MTG player; I mainly collect the cards because I love the art on them and I do have fun the few times that I do play. I think the only deck that plays Bob widely is probably Jund, there is still other black colour decks in Modern you can play such as Melira Pod, B/W Token, B/R burn etc. Sanguine Bond is a great enchantment to turn your lifegain effects into life loss for your opponents. Card tooltips provided by deckbox.org. about Magic: The Gathering, including card images, mana symbols, and Oracle text, sorts of discussions). There aren't enough cards that care about any other card type as much as creatures, and the card typing is has ramifications for other engines in the decks. Just paying six mana to Debt to the Deathless means that you drain two from each opponent and gain six life. Importantly for our evaluation, 31.7% of games end on or before Turn 4, and 50.81% of games end on or before Turn 5. No, but it was a heck of a lot closer than had I just mashed in some other "card advantage" card in the dark confidant spot. . Barandis It will cost you closer to 700$ with Thoughtseize Krayhaft it really depends on the deck, you can get some for 500$ which is what you would probably spend in a standard season buying a deck or two (in singles). Dark Confidant used to be a Legacy/Modern staple, but the times caught up to it. lol Is this a real question? rather than build a brand new deck. I was about to post a forum about this, and noticed that one was already right there. Does a summoned creature play immediately after being summoned by a ready action? Search for the perfect addition to your deck. MTG- 1x NM Foil Dark Confidant - MM2 - Modern Masters 2015 - Black Creature Near Mint - never played, opened and straight into sleeve and binder Shipping: MTG Singles under $20 - These will ship via envelope unless you contact me and ask me not. Add to Cart. Board & Card Games Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people who like playing board games, designing board games or modifying the rules of existing board games. Primary Menu. A split cards colors and converted mana cost are determined from its combined mana cost. The "Confidant curve" also manages to make the fifth land drop with fewer lands. Then you have to decide which 3-drop to play on turn three, making the unenviable choice of delaying your draw engine and Lili by a turn each, or delaying your draw engine by two turns. . ), Enduring Renewal is a White Enchantment that causes all creatures that are killed to go straight back into your hand instead of the graveyard. Dark Confidant (Custom Card Alternate Art) ad vertisement by MagicLCreations Ad from shop MagicLCreations MagicLCreations From shop MagicLCreations. As always, you're down the one card that it cost to cast the spell from your hand. Dark Confidant is a game changer in deck building. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. , they both do the same thing but one is banned in legacy, and other isn't even played in modern. Set Promo: General (Foil) $129.99) Condition: (Required) Near Mint. A young outsider of the town, his natural curiosity inspires the Finch children to study and question the world around them in ways that they had not previously considered. He explained it perfectly. being a justifiable consideration. I'm starting to hate these budget threads (you can say it isn't a budget thread, but you'd only be lying to yourself). Why does everyone say Dark Confident is better than Phyrexian Arena? It was just a little over a grand. In every zone except the stack, the characteristics of a split card are those of its two halves combined. only triggers if you have no cards in hand, otherwise it would be soooo busted. Its used as a win condition in mono-black decks. You have a 2 mana advantage engine, that keeps the life totals even by swinging for 2, that you can bolt to save yourself and that changes how you can curve out. If you cast Assault, the resulting spell is a red spell with a converted mana cost of 1. Youll lose some life, sure, but it shouldnt matter if you reanimated something good. Note that this analysis is identical to the one which would occur for Howling Mine and several other cards. Second turn: Again, the Confidant does not affect our draws so we still have the "basic curve" which tells us we want 8 two-drops and 15 lands, bringing our running total to 32 cards. , it wouldn't fit the mold as decks that use Dark Confidant The "basic curve" makes one play per turn for the first five turns, totaling five plays while the "Confidant curve" makes a total of eight plays over the same amount of turns. When that mana is colored, it's even more important. The fact it says draw lets you keep up an advantage engine in that sense as well as having a good stat line and similar. If you don't answer bob he will make you regret the fact you didn't address his board presence. of Available Items 3054 No. This means that from about Turn 3 or 4 Night's Whisper will generally be more valuable than a Bob cast on the same turn. may, and I mean may, have a place in Modern, but NOT as a direct substitute for Dark Confidant Dark Confidant: Those Secret Spells Will Cost Ya! We've added a "Necessary cookies only" option to the cookie consent popup. Do roots of these polynomials approach the negative of the Euler-Mascheroni constant? It was also totally worth the surprised looks on people's faces when they "knew" I had no outs, just for me to slam a titan down on them and take over the game. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Wizards of the Coast, Magic: The Gathering, and their logos are trademarks of Wizards of the Coast LLC. Unless you get some other value out of them therefore (Hi Najeela) I'm even more skeptical of them than of Bob, since I think it likely that they draw you fewer cards overall. Today Im taking a look at the best life loss effects in Magic. It can be very interesting in some EDH decks as well with cheap cards since youll drain the table for a bunch. in that deck because it does require that you blow your Lightning Bolt Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! Card Text: At the beginning of your upkeep, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. Card Name Dark Confidant. Compare Dark Confidant derrico family names and ages; llano uplift location . You lose life equal to its mana value. vs. That's all neither here nor there though. Popular posts: Why is Sundering Titan Banned in Commander? Kambal, Consul of Allocation has its place preventing combos in various formats. Discord Server | Fourth turn: This turn we play two two-drops and one land, which means we desire 20 of each in the deck, for a total of 52 cards. Graveyard Trespasser / Graveyard Glutton. ) and that's before you even get to $40+ Voice of Resurgence This card is such a lifedrainer in EDH. From there I thought it was worth looking at how much value we can expect from cards like Bob, Grob, and Mindblade.Speaking Grob and Mindblade, I did consider including them in the post, but decided against it because I didn't want to muddy the waters further. Life loss is its own sort of thing. This makes it a lot harder to justify playing a second playset of 1BB cards. EDIT: Also because he doesn't technically draw you cards, he gets around hate bears like Spirit of the Labyrinth. What is the purpose of this D-shaped ring at the base of the tongue on my hiking boots? Does Exchanging Life Totals Cause Loss of Life? You can exile up to two cards and drain your opponent for two life if it transforms. Rare and powerful MTG cards every player dreams of having in their decks! So if the player had 25 life at the beginning of the turn and ended the turn with 15 life, they effectively lost 10 life. From the rules: Specifically regarding CMC (emphasis mine): Example: Assault/Batterys mana cost is {3}{R}{G}. You have a 2 mana advantage engine, that keeps the life totals even by swinging for 2, that you can bolt to save yourself and that changes how you can curve out. Why? TappedOut.js Blog Widget. Privacy statement | Painful Truths saw some Legacy play, drawing three cards and losing three life. even better than Jund does. Can get cheaper threw trades and eBay deals. Exquisite Blood and Sanguine Bond are enchantments that go well together. February 8, 10. want that early card advantage to grind out an opponent with powerful cards.. like Liliana of the Veil It was the word "new" that threw me off. A comparable creature is grob, or mindblade render (less popular). 27 Timeless Ultimate Guides and Tools for Magic the Gathering, Siege Rhino: A Portent of Defeat for your Enemies, Berserk MTG Card: Temporary but fatal power. Providing a decently aggressive body and early card advantage, Dark Confidant was played everywhere. I was like "wtf this card sucks I lose life for it??" Even before that, the immediate value generated by Whisper has significant value. Dark Confidant - Modern Masters 2015 (MM2) Modern Masters 2015 All versions Direct by TCGplayer Lightly Played $17.75 Free Shipping on Orders Over $50 Sold by TheGamingCo 1 of 1 Add to Cart View 193 Other Listings As low as $15.59 Sell this Report a problem Product Details M #: 75 Creature Human Wizard P / T: 2 / 1 Flavor: Greatness, at any cost. The players have influence over what turn the game ends and so an just over half end on turn 5, not accounting for pod composition. a few years???? Damnation MTG Card: Destroy ALL Creatures! Well, partially it is because a simple 2-for-1 isn't particularly appealing - in a format with Ad Nauseum, Necropotence, Rhystic Study, Sylvan Library, etc, there isn't much need for a simple +1. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Again, it's about the mana. Our Privacy Policy. Dark Confidant (also affectionately known as " Bob "), released in Ravnica: City of Guilds, is a rare, black creature that allows its controller, at the beginning of his or her upkeep, to effectively draw an additional card at the cost of paying life equal to the card's converted mana cost. Description: At the beginning of your upkeep, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. That being said, this post had me look at the card again, and I'm not sure Bob is as great as one would hope in cEDH at the moment. I'm not looking for it to be super competitive yet, and Dark Depths is already killing the budget Phyrexian Arena would probably work in it until I get my hands on some confidants. OT: Comparing Dark Confidant and our There are a lot of very good reasons listed above for why Dark Confidant Saying DC is weaker than Liliana is almost impossible. The copyright for Magic: the Gathering and all associated card names and card images is held by Wizards of the Coast. in there, but im kind of thinking..why is he so good? This turn, having drawn two cards we want to play two spells and make our third land drop. Dark Confidant in the 2007 Pro Tour Season, Michael Belfatto's MBA 8th Place GP Columbus, Vitor Dama de Rosa's sideboard Worlds Legacy, O'Mahoney-Schwartz maindeck Worlds Legacy. and Verdant Catacombs Here he returns with an uplifting house cut that deftly manipulates samples . Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. I've been using the Arena and. Where as the modern deck will retain the same value for a good period of time and expect to sell at the same price you bought in to it with. I know I just bought it from tcgplayer. It is also worth noting that bob, grob and mindblade are all very easily tutorable due to their colors. Can get cheaper threw trades and eBay deals, Splintertwincombo price tag 665 maybe a lil less tcg mid price tcg. Thanks APPLE01DOJ and sylvannos, I'll see what I can do We can consider this closed, thanks to all who posted. Vendetta is a very efficient removal spell, but there are typically better alternatives available. Nimbus Maze: Got Blue but Need White? Cards Dark Confidant Dark Confidant (Card) $19.99 $17.54 0.2 TIX Average Type Distribution Land ( 30) Planeswalker ( 1) Enchantment ( 7) Artifact ( 12) Sorcery ( 10) Instant ( 15) Creature ( 24) Related Content Sep 3, 2021 Too-Specific Top 10 - Unscheduled Maintenance Double or nothing! The data for that post (which you can look at here) lists the number of times games ended on particular turns. For those who gamble, interest may even lead to the occasional, innocent experimentation with sleight-of-hand. If you cast Assault, the resulting spell is a red spell with a converted mana cost of 1. Because life loss doesnt count as damage, it doesnt count as noncombat damage either. rav-81-dark-confidant. Choose the options you'd like for the order. Thanks for all the feedback, guys! On top of this, the one or 2 cards you draw from Bob can be just enough to stop a win or win yourself, and if it goes past these number of turns, it becomes even more value. s at inopportune times to make sure you draw extra. I can't agree more. These cards love additional upkeep steps. Not bad. Oh, I'm well aware of its limitations. Ad Nauseam is a card that allows players to do unfair things. You could easily have to skip standard for the next few years just to fund a single modern deck. Phyrexian Arena is really the closest we have, and its pretty far from Dark Confidant's power level. And you do not have spend that much for a budget alternative. Children of Korlis gives you life equivalent to the lifeloss you had when you sacrifice it. With Blood Artist active each creature that dies (not just yours) results in lifegain for you, and lifeloss for your opponent. Its not that good for EDH since you target only one opponent, but the effect is still good. out of boosters. it depends on what modern and standard deck you're comparing. So selling all of those could have gotten me into modern. Neon Dynasty Featured a Hidden Praetor; Phyrexia: All Will Be One . Cruel Ultimatum, once a reason to play control and Grixis (), is still played in casual MTG. Cardmarket uses cookies and other related tools. If that same hand contained Arena and Lili instead, you can't spend any mana on turn 2. Help | 3) Dark Confidant costs 1 less which means he's in play earlier, and gets you at more cards sooner. advantages of masking animation. Modern Dredge, The Spookiest you can get in Modern. And besides this has turned into another thread all together. Pedro started playing Magic way back when in Fourth Edition. 12 one-drops, 22 two-drops, 4 three-drops, 21 lands. Youll draw lots of cards by paying life, and youll draw lots of rituals and cantrips which can result in a storm win in combo decks with cheap cards (0-1 mana value).