Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Not a bad sandwich at all, but theres just way too many condiments taking away the taste of whats important. in English Literature and foray through digital marketing, her life path was made abundantly clear. I can vouch from experience that it is freshly baked everyday. Top editors give you the stories you want delivered right to your inbox each weekday. The last memory I have of eating a Blimpie sandwich was in the Boy Scouts when I was probably 11 or 12 years old. However, there are some good reasons for this. I've only been to Jersey Mike's once so far but I liked it a lot. They also sell a smaller four-five inch sandwich for $6.29. The Italian dressing was a good idea. When I first started this sub chain showdown, I ultimately believed Jersey Mikes would be the eventual winner. After many travels during a B.A. The main appeal of Jimmy Johns sandwiches is the unique French bread they use. Italian: Bread: 6.1 Fillings: 5.8 Toppings: 3.6 Value: 6.4 Overall: 5.4, Firehouses Italian sub, left, and Blimpies Best. Everyone was giving thanks and eating their sliced turkey breast with all of the fixings. Photos I post are my own unless otherwise noted. From white and wheat bread baked fresh every day, to meats and cheeses sliced fresh for each sub, it's what they do here. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Grilled onions, peppers, white American cheese and chipotle mayo. I brought some friends and we tailgated in the parking lot, hunched over the hood of our cars, strands of lettuce and chunks of onions spilling out onto the wrapping and on my car. We're just surprised as you are that the Big Kahuna isn't the worst hot sub. Never happened.. There are Jimmy Johns shops everywhere, and most have a drive through. Order sandwich, state toppings, and off you go, Basically, EQUAL. Firehouse Subs also has a top-secret recipe for bread which is part of why their sandwiches always taste so fresh and delicious. Alex: Team Jimmy John's Instead of talking about our favorite sweet treats this Halloween weekend, Emma and I decided to test out our favorite cold cuts. Subs are prepared Mike's Way with onions, lettuce, tomatoes, oil, vinegar and spices. Every time I walk into a Firehouse Subs, I smell like one for the entire day. Tried one once and that was the end of going back there. For our ranking of cold subs, we primarily looked at calories, sodium, and fat, with bonus points awarded for protein. Which is better? Explained several times what I wanted. The top three sub chains in term of sales in America are Subway, Jimmy John's, and Jersey Mikes, according to Nation's Restaurant News. The "#5 Perfect Italian" sandwich at Jimmy John's cost $6.29 and was eight inches. I tried Primos once when I was in Philadelphia and remember being impressed, especially with its crusty sesame seeded bread. The beef is warmed up and then smothered in BBQ sauce. And what kind of lunatic orders a sandwich from Subway: this guy. Worst Subs on Jersey Mike's Menu. Poor customer service, poor quality of food and poor sandwich skills. By submitting comments you grant permission for all or part of those comments to appear in the print edition of New I loved all the spices, and the lettuce, tomato and onions, and you can add peppers if you want. Amazon.com: Jersey Mikes Gift Card $25. It was Black Friday and even after eating twice my own body weight in turkey, stuffing and mashed potatoes, I still craved a sandwich the next day. Provolone, ham, prosciuttini, and cappacuolo. The meat tasted very fresh, but I wish there was more of it. Were so lucky to have so many great sandwich options in New Jersey. Christiansburg, VA 24073. And although Jersey Mikes is more fresh, and tastes better, it is still a sandwich, and it may not be worth it to go out of you way to get one. Dont ask me how I know. var xhr = new XMLHttpRequest(); I love their food but damn their exhaust fans are horrible. These subs get "grilled" (their words, not mine) if you want them hot, which means another pass in the oven. Both sub shops had the usual culprits: turkey, ham, meatball, Italian, tuna, and cheese steak. EatThis.com is part of the AllRecipes Food Group. We decided to undertake this taste test of chain sub sandwiches in honor of National Eat a Hoagie Day, which this year falls on September 14. 8. It may be full of protein and have the least amount of sodium of the bunch, but we had to dock this sub for being high in calories, fat, and saturated fat. Kannon May 17, 2018 at 3:32 pm. It makes sense because Subway is cheap and consistent you know what you're going to get and you're not going to spend too much. Much like Moses, the Jersey Mike's legend starts by the water and seems improbable. It had smoked ham, hard salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, Roma tomatoes, red onions, banana peppers, olive oil & red wine vinegar, salt & pepper, oregano, mayo. I know everyones got their favorite order, but for the sake of this debate, I stuck with the Italian hoagie. Fast food cheeseburgers, ranked fromworst to best. There is no better way to cure a craving than with some fresh cold cuts. There is not a lot of meat on this small sandwich, and it's incredibly dry. The potbelly bread was the heartiest of the breads, and tasted very fresh. Both are good, but I prefer Jersey Mike's over Jimmy John's. This a big positive. They even cook their roast beef in house. But the regular medium-sized sub goes for $8, which pushes it over the edge a bit. The toppings are also neatly tucked inside so nothing falls out. While the sandwiches are good, it's the toppings that really push them . We mean, it's quite the mouthful: packed with grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms, jalapeosand extra cheeseyour saving grace is basically the fact that there's no mayo-based sauce adding an absurd amount of fat. What a sad sandwich this was. This - all day. (from the 1600 Tonnelle Avenue, North Bergen location), I havent had Subway in years, and cant believe I ever liked it. 601 Shenandoah Village Drive. "This sub has the least amount of saturated and trans fats of almost all the subs," says L.J. Olivia Tarantino is the Managing Editor of Eat This, Not That!, specializing in nutrition, health, and food product coverage. I cant say I was surprised by the quality, but I was surprised that for nearly $6 for the six-inch Italian, that people still order it. We were looking for that perfect combo of high quality meat and cheese, on great bread, and fresh toppings that create an incredible sandwich. Lots of herb-y-ness made it interesting. ), this is a really tasty sub. Furthermore, Michigan Live said it best when they described Subway's sandwiches as 'always tasting the same.' Gonzo: There is something about the Jimmy John's bread that Im not a fan of, I just dont really like it. We had the "Original Italian" with provolone, ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, salami and pepperoni. But at Jimmy Johns, all I got was one sandwich. Gonzo: I dont even want to talk about Subway. Then, I scored each sandwich from 1-10 based on the quality of bread, fillings (meats and cheese), toppings (lettuce, tomatoes, onions, etc), and value. Jimmy John's, it's only a mile away from my work; to get to the local Jersey Mike's, I'd have to get on Route 1, deal with either a U-Turn, long traffic lights, and the rest of the shopping centers. No, not a pizza, but a pie with tomatoes in it. Not only are 250 of those calories entirely from mayo, but there's also more sodium in the entire sub than you should eat in an entire day. There are plenty more unsuspecting foods with more fat than a Big Mac. Needless to say, it was not great. For places I can go fairly regularly (none of the above convenient to home or work), I wind up at DiBella's once or twice a month and it's always been good. Well our bodies excrete waste, but do we want it, just because it comes with our bodies? Jersey Mike's bacon is actually bacon. Everyone I talk to either likes Jimmy John's by a mile or has never tasted Jersey Mike's. It needed a boost somewhere. This chain does get points for its long-running history and a generous serving of vegetables, but that's about it. I will never return agian. When Subway, Jersey Mikes, Fire House Subs, Jimmy Johns, and Publix go head to head which sub wins? The Stickball Special knocks it out of the park when it comes to serving up nearly an entire day's recommended intake of sodium and just over half of the recommended amount of saturated fat you should consume in a day. I cant say I was surprised that Primos made a great sub, but its probably the closest you can get to an authentic Italian deli sandwich from chain. A sub by any other name hero, hoagie, grinder is just as delicious. So if youre ever in dire straits, need a quick sub fix, and have to resort to a chain, heres my ranking of the best ones. I used to live a block away from one. 62 Media Group, a division of New Jersey Monthly, creates custom print and digital publications that help build customer relationships and drive more sales. Metairie, LA 70006-5439. So how can they come in last? Sometime years ago, I visited my grandfather in North Carolina, and we went over to his friends house for dinner. Doesn't JJ only use provolone cheese, with no options for anything else? There was a good meat to bun ratio, and great acidity from the dressing to balance it out, while not sogging up the bread. You'll be surprised a. Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Thousand Island dressing. Located in downtown Englewood, I drove down memory lane, passing by some old lunch haunts and hangouts. xhr.open('POST', 'https://www.google-analytics.com/collect', true); Youll have to give me the recipe! I was in complete shock. The thing about Subway is that it tastes exactly like Subway. Tod i ordered but was told it is out of our area, the store is 3/4 of a mile down the street. All the vegetables are sliced in house, fresh throughout the day. Our website collected and compiled various consumer reviews about Jersey Mikes Subs and Jimmy Johns as well as customer ratings and recommendations for these brands. I would say I prefer Jimmy Johns for the "freaky fast" food. Weekend Buzz: Weekly, Events and Entertainment, Side dish: Weekly, Dining News and Reviews, ShoreCast: Weekly, Best of the New Jersey Shore, Specials: Occasional, Exclusive Contests, Deals and Offers, Occasional, Exclusive Contests, Deals and Offers, Rachel Zeglers Jersey Upbringing Prepared Her for Stardom, Middle Eastern Grill to Offer Free Items in Paramus; Other Dining News, Philly-Raised Chef Embraces South Jersey: It Has Such a Good Feeling, Englewood Mural Honors Black Womens Voices, Mahwah Farm Gives Those With Special Needs a Chance to Horse Around, Amid Global Shortages, NJ Breweries Look to Source More Locally, Five Star Real Estate Agents in New Jersey, Five Star Mortgage Professionals in New Jersey, Five Star Home/Auto Insurance Professionals in New Jersey. And the provolone had a slight funk to it. It is very likely you will find one on whatever road you are on, and you will receive your sandwich before you can even finish ordering. We chose to analyze the nutrition of each sub with traditional white bread and at the regular size (7-1/2 inches). Known for their cheesesteak, Penn Station also serves a variety of other sandwiches. While the sandwiches are good, it's the toppings that really push them over the edge of flavor falls. Publix is the best of course, glad that's acknowledged. Jersey Mike's allows for much more customization, and it seems to taste a little fresher than Jimmy John's. By comparison, a six inch Subway turkey only has 280 calories and 4 grams of fat. PissedConsumer.com strives to provide consumers with the right information to make informed purchasing decisions. Jimmy John's. The great thing about Jimmy John's is that customers can get actual sandwiches on regular bread along with subs. I went to all three sandwich chains and ordered the same . I also appreciate the amount of meat on this sandwich, but it surprisingly didnt have much flavor. Both Jimmy Johns and Jersey Mike have good customer service for fast food sandwich shops. There is a JJs in Monroe on US 165 north of I-20, and the other 2 are located in Shreveport. While many believe that Subway is the best chain in terms of flavor, they're actually pretty low on the list when it comes to the freshness and flavors that Jersey Mike's is adding to each sub. Their flavors are good but that's all it is - just good. I did like the meats, you could taste each one. } Amy: The "juice" is what did it for me. Gonzo: I like how loaded it came, and the meats here were really nice. But first, we have one burning sub-related question to answer. I ordered the Vito with salami, capicola, and provolone with shredded lettuce, tomatoes, white onions, oil, vinegar, oregano and basil. The heavier ingredients slide out while you're eating since they're stacked closer to the front. There was a decent amount of meat but it wasnt anything special. The biggest complaint we had with this sandwich is its construction. The Original Italian: Bread: 5.4 Fillings: 6.9 Toppings: 7.1 Value: 4.7 Overall: 6.0, Jersey Mikes Original Italian sub, left, and Jimmy Johns Vito sub. Fun fact: Jimmy Johns has nearly 3,000 locations across the country but only three current locations in NJ. For customers with gluten allergies or sensitivities, Jimmy Johns offers what they call and unwich, with is the sandwich ingredients, wrapped up in lettuce. I apologize that I dont really have any dirt or juicy details regarding how the sandwiches are prepared. every day. The price, quality, and convenience are all worth it. And eat local, at one of our many fabulous Michigan's Best establishments if you can. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. The other benefit of this chain is the speed behind the actual creation of the sandwich, making them one of the faster sandwich chains out there. Subway's bread, while tasty and durable when toasted, has been limited to the same flavors for years (with the exception of a new flavor added here and there) and does have a tendency to get soggy with condiments such as oil and vinegar. Jimmy John sandwiches are vegan. I think Jimmy John's has the better bread, but I like the meat and really like the vinegar that Jersey Mike's have. Maybe it's because The Veggie is mostly made up of trans-fat-laden cheeses. Convenience is key, people. We're as shocked as you are, and frankly, rather disappointed it ranks so poorly against the competition. For example, a Burger King Whopper comes in at a literally whopping 670 calories and 39 grams of fat. I ordered the Original Italian with provolone, ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, salami and pepperoni, and got it Mikes Way with white onions, lettuce, tomatoes, vinegar, oil and spices. Adding ham to The Number Four tacks on about 275 milligrams of sodium and 40 calories. Jersey Mike's. Jimmy Johns has multiple locations throughout the town, as well as drive through and delivery services. It's a little bit surprising, for sure, to see a sandwich chain such as Subway toward the bottom of the list. For more great stories, head to INSIDER's homepage. Industry, tourism and local traffic would be gone or severely crippled without it being in functioning condition in BOTH states. She says, "It has the most sodium, sugar and saturated fat out of all the sandwiches. Im aware each location differs a bit on quality, so this is all based on my own experience. The meats were also sliced thin and tasted fresh, salty and savory. } The Best Sandwich Chains, Ranked In Order Of Delicious To 'I'd Rather Have Pizza', A good sandwich has the capability to make anything better, The Best Pancakes At IHOP, Ranked For Scientific Flavor Purposes, While Subway may have the lead as one of the most popular, Pizza Party: Ranking Every Major Pizza Chain From Worst To Best (Sorry Not Sorry), Ranking Wendy's Best Menu Items, Including Their New Jalapeo Popper Chicken Sandwich. All the lettuce was in the pocket, and all the meat on outside. Everything on this one kind of melded into one flavor, which was pretty good. Get the best food tips and diet advice They have a ton of sauces to choose from too. So for the same price you can get an eight-inch sandwich at Jimmy John's or something half the size at Jersey Mike's. Now thats a lot. So, depending on what you like or want, it was possible to spend six dollars at both places. So here are eight different chain subs that we tried, so you don't have to. Amaral says it's without a doubt The Original Italian. Primo Italian: Bread: 7.0 (wouldve been higher with seeded bread) Fillings: 7.8 Toppings: 7.6 Value: 7.2 Overall: 7.4, Best Bread: Jimmy Johns Best Fillings: Primo Hoagies Best Toppings: Primo Hoagies Best Value: QuickChek Biggest Surprise: QuickChek Biggest Disappointment: Wawa. We mean AMAZING. All vegetables are prepped fresh every day. Youre basically just tasting a vinegar sub. If you're going to order the Big Kahuna, we'd rather you get the chicken version over the beef one. How much brain power does it take to say.. Got to Somerset location at 5:53. I ordered the same meal at each place: an Italian-style sub sandwich with chips, a cookie, and a drink. Jersey Mikes of course. Here in New Jersey, no one should ever have to rely on any kind of deli sandwich chain. Typically, I'll spend $10-11 at Jersey Mike's, and $8-9 at Jimmy John's, so it depends on how much I want to spend. It might be named after the beaches of the Garden State, but with the amount of bloat-inducing sodium you'll find in this sub, you won't be looking too bikini body ready. Why? They were never anything special, but it was convenient, quick, and cheap. There is the mini, regular, giant, wrap, and tub. I called, and bc Niomi said it was ready 8:53 she would not have time to make my sub bc they closed! We hit the streets and went to Jimmy John's, then to Jersey Mike's, and two sandwiches later, picked our favorites. Jersey Mike's: Sub in a Tub and/or. It may not rack up as much sodium as the subs surrounding it, but we deduced points from this loaded sub because of the lower protein content. It's filling, it's good and it's excellent. JMs are more harder to find than JJs, by and large. I have had Jersey Mikes more than Jimmy Johns because of its close proximity to the AMC movie theater, and I was a little bit apprehensive to go somewhere I was not as familiar with. I ordered the same sandwichan Italian subfrom each chain. Applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing. The ingredients are fine, but its nothing special. Michigan's Best pizza can be found across the state. Unlike the traditional club sub below it, this club is made up of roast beef and swiss instead of the ham and provolone. At both places I had a sandwich on traditional bread, with turkey, provolone, lettuce, mayonnaise. Lets dig in. Italian Hoagie: Bread: 4.1 Fillings: 3.7 Toppings: 4.0 Value: 5.8 Overall: 4.4, (from the 41 West Palisade Avenue, Englewood location). JJs is ok but more in tune with Subways taste. Its off of a busy main road and a side street with a small amount of parking spots. I'm not really sure what this means, so I'll be doing some hard hitting journalism to find out for you, because that does sound different. The tomatoes and onions didnt add much here but were obviously a requirement and they didnt disappoint. You will be able to edit the text before publishing. if( navigator.sendBeacon ) { But I shook my head and just dove in and took a bite. Ill be honest here. Hit the lanes at some of the best bowling alleys in Michigan. The flavor was decent, and you get some of each ingredient in every bite because of how it's layered. Gonzo: I obviously didn't care for the presentation, but it had a lot of meat on it and a lot of flavor too. Lets get something straight. They claim to be unique in "steaming" their meats and cheeses before loading them onto the fresh baked bread. Gonzo: To me it tastes the most homemade out of any of the chains. Jersey Mike's Subs - The Fake Foodie. Jimmy John's (from the 110 1st Street, Jersey City location) Full disclosure: I used to work at a Jimmy John's in Illinois, so I've witnessed its rise to success and eventual expansion to my home state. xhr.setRequestHeader('Content-Type', 'text/plain;charset=UTF-8'); Customer service. I used to work at Jimmy John's, and Jersey Mike's is much better. In fact, getting a veggie sub here might be the best idea. The fresh factor doesn't just stop there, though - Jersey Mike's is also cooking their own roast beef and making their signature sauce with a secret oil blend and vinegar. kyle Aug 26, 2019 at 9:13 am, Jimmy Johns is so much better than Jersey Mikes its unbelievable. I finally gave Jimmy Johns a fair try today to compare to Jersey Mikes. Ah Wawa, a New Jersey and Pennsylvania institution. The meat is blah, but the vegetables are fresh and abundant. John Gonzalezon Twitter@michigangonzo, as well asFacebookandInstagram @MichiganGonzo. My friends and I sat at our cloth-less, bare brown fold-up table waiting for our den leader to show up with dinner. This sandwich was also very cold, meaning all of the ingredients had probably been sitting there for a while. US 101 is THE backbone of the Pacific coast from Bandon OR to Willets CA. (which stands for biggest, meatiest, tastiest), all of which were inaccurate. My goal: to find out how these hoagie hawkers stack up. 2 seconds turned into 20 minutes of waiting along with other multiple frustrated patrons We will not be back to this location and will be advising our town that as long as these two are working there not to eat there. Not terrible. They also are popular for their hand cut french fries, which I'll be going back to sample for you later. as well as other partner offers and accept our, According to foodservice research company, 's 2017 chain restaurant study, reported on by. Check out my gear on Kit: https://kit.com/mrchrisyoungIt's a battle of the subs. Jimmy Johns is also MUCH more affordable. They use a lean turkey breast with no additives and flavorful provolone cheese. A community to share news, events, gatherings, stories, and more for everyone that calls The Holy City (and the surrounding communities in Berkeley, Charleston and Dorchester Counties) home. The Italian comes with Genoa salami, spicy pepperoni, Black Forest ham, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, green peppers, cucumbers, oil and vinegar.